Eight Years on Xianyu: My Guide to Buying and Haggling
- No.
- 127
- Date
- Read
- 9 min
- Words
- 2,018
How do you find things worth buying on Xianyu?
It's an interesting question. I started on Xianyu as a buyer, and at first I had plenty of questions about buying there.
- What can you buy on Xianyu?
- What if it breaks after I get it?
- This price seems too high. How do I haggle?
- This price seems too low. Could it be a trap?
- What if the seller keeps pushing me to confirm receipt after I get the package?
In short, I'm sure many people have had, or still have, some doubts about buying on Xianyu.
I've used Xianyu for eight years. I've sold 185 items and bought 257 on it, so my experience with buying there might help you.
What Can You Buy on Xianyu?
Let me think about what I've bought on Xianyu.
- Most of all, electronics: phones, computers, cameras, lenses.
- Next, cycling gear, like clipless shoes, jerseys, and bib shorts. All of it new.
- Then services. What I buy most is shared family plans for iCloud or Xiaomi Cloud, and after that, membership top-ups.
- Last, digital goods. I often buy K-drama sources on Xianyu. There are lots of 4K K-dramas there, priced at around one fen to one jiao.
Those are the things I buy on Xianyu most often. Many people treat Xianyu as a secondhand platform, but plenty of individuals and shops sell brand-new things there too.
Take the cycling clipless shoes I bought. On the brand's official flagship store they sell for 799 yuan, and on Xianyu I paid only 440 for a brand-new, genuine pair. So-called gray-channel goods like this are everywhere on Xianyu, and not just in cycling gear. Probably in many other fields too.
Almost all of my cycling gear came from Xianyu. Even the new bike I got at the start of this year, I put together part by part from Xianyu. I've also picked up two desktop computers there in the past.
My motives for buying on Xianyu mostly come from my interests and actual needs. Whether it's electronics, cycling gear, or services and digital goods, they all fit two traits: "I'm interested in it" and "I need it."
So what you can buy on Xianyu depends on what you're interested in and what you need. Everyone answers those two questions differently, so everyone sees different things there.
What If It Breaks After I Get It?
The biggest fear in buying secondhand is that something's wrong with the item once you get it, and then you end up in a dispute.
So the first thing we need to do is avoid buying a broken item to begin with.
How do you avoid that? First, learn to size up the seller.
Take me. Whenever I buy something, I always click through to the seller's profile to take a look. Now I have a few rules.
- No Sesame Credit authorization, no deal.
- Sesame Credit only average or poor, no deal.
- Default Xianyu profile picture, no deal.
- Too many bad reviews, or bad reviews that are way out of line, no deal.
With these, I can avoid most of the risks of buying. But sizing up a seller goes beyond that. Besides reputation and profile picture, you also need to tell individual sellers apart from shops.
- Most sellers of everyday goods are individuals.
- Shops show up in areas like brand-new goods, top-up services, electronics, and musical instruments.
- An individual seller's listings are usually quite random. Their profile may show items from many categories.
- A shop's profile usually has a more uniform set of categories.
- Telling individuals and shops apart is a fairly important step in sizing up a seller.
- But keep in mind that shops and individual sellers aren't fundamentally different. There are differences in some cases, but it doesn't mean a shop will definitely rip you off. Sometimes a shop is far more straightforward than an individual.
All right. You've sized up the seller and finally agreed on a deal. What do you need to do to avoid ending up with the wrong item?
- First, once you've finished chatting, paid, and closed the deal, send one more message in the chat: "One last confirmation: it's never been opened or repaired, and everything works, right?" The key to this step is having a record in the chat confirming the item works properly.
- Second, after the item arrives, it's best to film yourself unboxing it. Start from opening the box and keep recording through unpacking the item, checking its exterior, and testing its functions, all in one video. Generally, when you buy valuable items or precision electronics, this step is a must. For everyday goods, where problems are less likely, you can decide case by case.
These two steps are what you need in order to get through the return process if you do end up with a faulty item.
- The chat record makes sure the seller has acknowledged that the item is definitely fine.
- The unboxing video shows you haven't touched it, and it was broken the moment you got it.
In these situations, most honest sellers agree to a return. If you run into a bad seller who does this on purpose, you can go to Xianyu's dispute jury and have customer service step in. Upload your chat record and video evidence, and it will help a lot in the ruling.
Besides these systematic steps, two more things can lower your chances of buying a faulty item.
- Don't be greedy for a cheap price. Always remember that you get what you pay for. You might get something thirty or a hundred yuan cheaper. But if what you're buying is several hundred or a thousand yuan under the secondhand market price, think hard about whether it's a big bargain or a big landmine.
- Choose in-person trades. In-person trades are without doubt the most reliable. You meet face to face and check the item. If something's wrong, you walk away, and if not, you close the deal. This works for many people.
The Price Seems Too High. How Do I Haggle?
Haggling when you buy on Xianyu is a well-worn topic.
I first learned about Xianyu in middle school, from a teacher at the education center where I had a summer job the summer I graduated.
I still remember something he said back then: you can haggle on Xianyu.
Honestly, as someone born in the 2000s, I never had a habit of haggling. I think many people my age don't bargain even when buying vegetables at the market.
But now I'll say this: if you can't haggle, don't use Xianyu.
Because sellers on Xianyu these days all list their prices a bit high, expecting you to haggle. If you don't, you must be very rich!
So before you haggle, the first thing to get past is your own mindset. Understand there's nothing to be embarrassed about.
The person you're chatting with is just an ordinary person. If you think the price is high, haggle. If you can agree on a price both sides are happy with, buy it. If you can't, don't. It's that simple.
Before you haggle, you first need to know: what does this thing usually sell for? With a market price to refer to, you can haggle calmly.
Xianyu is a very full-featured app now, and there are two ways to quickly find out roughly what something is worth.
- First, search for what you want to buy and browse a bunch of listings to see their average asking price. That gives you a sense of the range.
- Second, use Xianyu's "Market Prices" feature to see the item's recent completed orders and their final prices.
One is the average asking price, and the other is the price of past completed orders. Knowing both, you'll basically have a clear idea of what the item can sell for.
And once you know what it can sell for, you naturally know where you stand when you haggle.
How you haggle depends partly on the item itself, and partly on what you want.
- What affects an item's price?
- How long it's been used
- Whether everything works
- Whether it's been repaired
- Whether the original box and proof of purchase are included
- Whether there are flaws or dents on the exterior
- At what price do you want to buy it?
- Below market price? (Short on budget)
- Above market price? (Plenty of budget, just want something you like)
- Or roughly the market price? (Not after the lowest price, just a fair one)
So combine the factors that affect the price with what you want yourself, and you can start haggling.
As for how to open, it's really simple: just say what you think.
Since it's a public platform, listings are put up to be sold and I'm browsing to buy. Everyone is sincerely buying and sincerely selling, so there's no need for a lot of ceremony.
You can just ask: "Boss, would XXX yuan work?"
Note: name the price you want to pay directly. Don't ask "What's the lowest you'll go?"
Usually the actual condition of the item doesn't differ much from the seller's listing page. So in most cases, you can open the chat and haggle right away. Once the seller agrees, confirm some details about the item, and then pay.
The Price Is Too Low. Could It Be a Trap?
Friend, when you start to think you've been scammed, you probably already have been.
So please stop wondering about this pointless question. As I said above, when you buy something several hundred yuan under the secondhand market price, you take on both the value that price brings and the risks that may sit behind it.
I've been on Xianyu for eight years. Even staying on guard the whole time, I've been burned twice.
So now when I buy on Xianyu, I never go in looking for a steal. That's a very dangerous mindset. If you're an ordinary buyer, you're better off aiming for a fair market price.
What If the Seller Keeps Pushing Me to Confirm Receipt?
A bit of background first. Xianyu is still at heart a secondhand trading platform, so its transaction system is different from Taobao or JD.
On Xianyu, the flow is: place the order, pay, seller ships, buyer receives the package (courier marks it delivered), confirm receipt, payment released.
The difference is that after the courier marks the package delivered, Xianyu doesn't pay the seller right away. The money is held in an escrow account.
Once you've received the package and checked that everything works, you can tap "Confirm Receipt," and only then does the platform pay the seller.
So many sellers ask the buyer to tap "Confirm Receipt" once the package arrives, so they can get paid.
But what if I haven't checked whether it's good, or I want to use it for a few more days?
My advice is: that's fine. Use it a few more days if you like, as long as you're not trying to game the system.
Under Xianyu's current rules, 72 hours after the courier marks it delivered, the platform confirms receipt automatically.
It used to be ten days, which was truly agonizing for sellers.
Three days now is a fairly reasonable time. On one hand, buyers can use the item within three days, which is enough to find out if something's wrong. On the other, sellers don't have to wait too long.
In the past, I also used to nudge buyers to confirm receipt. Since it changed to three days, I haven't done that once.
If you think there's a problem with the item, you can use the extend-receipt feature. You can extend once and choose how long. I think the longest is 15 days (I've never used it).
Final Thoughts
Most people selling on Xianyu are normal people. Learning to size up sellers already raises your success rate in shopping a lot.
This is the second post in my Xianyu guide series. In the future I'll write a few more on how to sell, how to buy and sell electronics, and the traps I've fallen into.