"On Practice" Is So Good It Makes Me Cry (Part 1)

No.
119
Date
Read
8 min
Words
1,714

Hi, I'm Xiluluke.

Lately I've been thinking about "dialectical minimalism." Thinking it through deeply, I realized: since I'm taking dialectical materialism and minimalism as the foundations of this idea, do I myself still understand what dialectical materialism is, and what minimalism is?

To deal with what's outside, first set your own house in order. I'm happy to say that, under my influence, both of my friends in "Between the Lines" have started reading the Selected Works of Mao Zedong. So I'm planning to reread "On Contradiction" and "On Practice" soon.

I'll turn my reading notes into posts to share with more friends who are interested in "On Practice" and "On Contradiction."

I'll try to make these notes very detailed. I have one small wish: that these notes might actually get some people to read the original.

A note up front: as Chairman Mao said, everyone lives as a member of a particular class. So do I. My readings and notes represent only my personal views. Because everyone's class is different and everyone's practice in life is different, it's perfectly normal to see things differently. I hope we can seek common ground while setting aside differences, and make progress together.


Man's social practice is not confined to activity in production, but takes many other forms: class struggle, political life, scientific and artistic pursuits; in short, as a social being, man participates in all spheres of the practical life of society.

What is practice? Every sphere of the practical life of society involves human practice. On the one hand, studying and working are practice. On the other, relationships with people, birth, aging, sickness and death, partings, the give-and-take of social obligations, exercise: all of these can be called practice too.

Practice means the system problems a person faces, one after another.


In class society everyone lives as a member of a particular class, and every kind of thinking, without exception, is stamped with the brand of a class.

This is why young people sometimes feel that what experts say is out of touch with reality.

Everyone lives in a particular class position. Different class positions produce different perceptual knowledge, and each produces its own practice. It's like the celebrity on a variety show who once asked, "Why would there be a bowl in the fridge?" A person's class position limits the range of their practice.

Never mind class. Even two families' kids in the same apartment complex, on the same floor, will be brought up into two different kids because of their parents' differences.

If two families in the same class differ this much, how much more two classes? So the existence of class isn't what's frightening. What's frightening is seeing only a spot of the leopard through a tube and not knowing it.


Marxists hold that man's social practice alone is the criterion of the truth of his knowledge of the external world. What actually happens is that man's knowledge is verified only when he achieves the anticipated results in the process of social practice (material production, class struggle or scientific experiment). If a man wants to succeed in his work, that is, to achieve the anticipated results, he must bring his ideas into correspondence with the laws of the objective external world; if they do not correspond, he will fail in his practice.

Here Chairman Mao says two things.

First, all ideas have to be tested by practice. A very simple example: an adult tells a child that water puts out fire. For the child, that's just someone else's experience. Only when he actually puts out a fire with water is the statement proved by the act.

Second, you have to bring your ideas into correspondence with the laws of the objective world. This connects to what the previous paragraph said, that "man's activity in production develops step by step from a lower to a higher level." Human practice is the same. It has a process of development.

What does it mean to correspond with the laws of the objective world? A very simple example: if a company develops a product without doing market research, that's a failure to understand the objective laws. And what does combining the subjective and the objective mean? When a company builds a product, everyone hopes it will be a hit. That's the subjective.

But who will buy it? How many people? How much will they pay? How long will it sell? These are objective laws you can only draw out through careful market research.


The Marxist philosophy of dialectical materialism has two outstanding characteristics. One is its class nature: it openly avows that dialectical materialism is in the service of the proletariat. The other is its practicality: it emphasizes the dependence of theory on practice, emphasizes that theory is based on practice and in turn serves practice.

Practice exists at every stage in the development of knowledge. From a vague first impression of something, to a gradually clearer understanding of it, to finally grasping its essence: the practice in the whole process is all for the sake of pushing practice further.


In the process of practice, man at first sees only the phenomenal side, the separate aspects, and the external relations of things.

Take my job as an example. My job is repairing machines, and repairing machines tests how well you grasp the internal relations of things.

Say the sample probe on a device is bent. If I can only see the external relations of things, my fix will be to bend the probe straight and leave it at that.

But if I want to get to the internal relations of things, I'll look into what causes the probe to bend.

If the cause happens only by chance, then what is the factor behind that chance occurrence?

That's digging into the internal relations of things: seeing the essence of the problem, grabbing it, and solving it, so the problem may be solved once and for all.


To repeat, rational knowledge differs from perceptual knowledge, because perceptual knowledge pertains to the separate aspects, the phenomena and the external relations of things, whereas rational knowledge, taking a big step forward, reaches the totality, the essence and the internal relations of things and discloses the inner contradictions in the surrounding world.

This is how "On Practice" guides ordinary people's real lives. From this angle, Chairman Mao taught us to see the essence through the phenomena and analyze problems: to step outside our own isolated view, gather material from many angles and many levels, and finally strike straight at the heart of it.

Read together with "On Contradiction," this means grasping how contradictions develop, telling apart the changes in principal and secondary contradictions, and resolving them.


The solution of all these problems is inseparable from practice. Whoever wants to know a thing has no way of doing so except by coming into contact with it, that is, by living (practising) in its environment.

What's the cause and effect here? It's what I said above: practice exists at every stage in the development of knowledge, and the practice in the whole process is all for the sake of pushing practice further.

Since practice exists at every stage in the development of knowledge, it should exist in every part of our lives.

So if you want to understand something, you have to make it part of your life.

Take using AI today. If you want to learn it, you have to let it show up in your life more, and that's how you build the most basic environment.


All knowledge originates in perception of the objective external world through man's physical sense organs. Anyone who denies such perception, denies direct experience, or denies personal participation in the practice that changes reality, is not a materialist.

How do I understand this passage? Accepting that knowledge comes from direct experience and perception of the objective world is really accepting that things have a process of development.

Everything has a process of development. Peeling an apple with a knife, you start with a whole apple and peel your way down until it's an apple with the skin off.

So accepting this isn't hard. If you feel you can't understand it, it's not that you're wrong, and it's not that he's wrong.

You just haven't yet formed an awareness of the Marxist view of development.

Dialectical materialism is a system, and "On Practice" and "On Contradiction" are just two gears in that huge system.

To study materialist dialectics in depth, you have to study the relevant knowledge and concepts of Marxism systematically.

A book I recommend: A Course in the Principles of Marxist Philosophy


Knowledge begins with practice, and theoretical knowledge is acquired through practice and must then return to practice.

Take Steve Jobs as an example.

Some people think Jobs was an extreme hippie. Some think he was a genius.

But none of those judgments matter. What matters is that Jobs used his own theory to create his products. He proved his theory through practice.

If Jobs had only believed that "a product must not break the Zen" and never made anything, the theory would have stayed empty talk in the end.

But Jobs used his philosophy and theory to create the Mac and the iPhone. That's the best example of "theoretical knowledge is acquired through practice and must then return to practice."

If you told Jobs you were also a practitioner seeking Zen, he'd just answer: "Then have you ever made anything like the iPhone?" Not to mock you, but because any theory should land on a starting point in practice. We should talk less and do more.


Rational knowledge can be relied on precisely because it has its source in sense perceptions, otherwise it would be like water without a source, a tree without roots, subjective, self-engendered and unreliable.

We often say creativity is the act of making new connections between old ideas, or of recognizing relationships between concepts. From this passage, I take it that creativity is born gradually, along with the development from perceptual knowledge to rational knowledge.

To make new connections in things or truly understand the relationships between different concepts, you can't start from simple perceptual knowledge. You first have to develop your knowledge of a thing to the rational stage.

Licensed under CC BY-NC 4.0. Please credit the author and link to xiluluke.com/en/8292

Xiluluke

A dialectical minimalist writing about life, reading and thinking.

Comments

0 / 2000Plain text · Line breaks preserved
Comment as

Loading comments…

    Your browser remembers your name and email once you post.

    Related writing

    WeChat · Xiluluke

    WeChat QR code for Xiluluke

    Scan with WeChat, or long-press to save the image.

    Open original ↗

    Buy me a coffee · Xiluluke

    WeChat reward code for Xiluluke
    WeChat
    Alipay code for Xiluluke
    Alipay

    Scan with WeChat or Alipay, or long-press to save the image.