Vol. 8: Without Contradiction There Is No World: Why Contradiction Is Everywhere, from "On Contradiction"

No.
199
Date
Read
12 min
Words
2,716

There's something I bet you've done too.

You finish sending someone an important message, or a slightly embarrassing one. Your finger is still on the screen, and almost instantly you flip the phone face down, look away, and pretend to do something else. In that moment there's a little calculation in your head: as long as I don't look, whether they've replied and what they said hasn't happened yet. The answer that's making my chest tight is still hanging in midair. It hasn't landed.

But deep down you know perfectly well. Before long you'll flip the phone back over and open that message. The answer has been there all along, from the second you hit send. It won't get any gentler because you looked away a little longer.

I'm starting with this because at the end of the last post, I left a question unanswered.

We had just covered the two world outlooks at the start of "On Contradiction" and learned that the roots of change lie in a thing's internal contradiction. But right away a doubt popped up: is contradiction really that universal? Could it be that contradiction only exists when something goes wrong, when there's conflict, when you're unlucky, and when things are smooth and peaceful there's no such thing?

That habit of looking away after sending a message already brushes against the answer. You look away because there's something there you don't want to face. And whether it's there has nothing at all to do with whether you look at it.

This post answers that question: is contradiction isolated and occasional, or is it everywhere, all the time?

What Mao Means by "Universal"

I covered the background of "On Contradiction" in the last post: 1937, Yan'an, Mao lecturing on philosophy to cure the Party's dogmatism at the level of method of thought. I won't go over it again.

After the two world outlooks, the first thing he sets out to prove is the universality of contradiction. He's very direct about it. This universality has two meanings.

First, contradiction is in everything:

Contradiction exists in the process of development of all things.

Note the word "all." It's not that some things have it and others don't, or that troublesome things have it and pleasant things don't. Anything at all, as long as it exists, holds contradiction inside it.

Second, contradiction is there all the time:

In the process of development of each thing a movement of opposites exists from beginning to end.

This one is about time. From the start of something to its end, contradiction never stops for a moment. It's not there at the start and quiet in the middle, and it's not that once you resolve one, all is peaceful. It runs from beginning to end without a break.

To bring the two together, Mao quotes a line from Engels:

Motion itself is a contradiction.

That line is the key to the whole idea of universality. As long as something is moving, changing, going forward, there's a pair of things inside it pulling against each other yet inseparable. And the reverse holds too:

There is nothing that does not contain contradiction; without contradiction nothing would exist.

Your instinctMao's view
When is there contradiction?Only when something goes wrong, there's conflict, or you're unluckyIn everything, in good times and bad
When things go smoothlyNo contradiction, which is why it's smoothContradiction is still there, just held down for now or unseen
What contradiction meansSomething bad, a fault to be eliminatedA neutral normal state, proof that a thing is alive and moving

The first time I read "without contradiction nothing would exist," I resisted it a bit. I thought, isn't that overstating it? I've had plenty of smooth days in my life without any contradiction at all.

Later it slowly sank in that the problem was the word "contradiction." In everyday speech, contradiction means arguments, conflict, falling out, opposition with emotion in it. What Mao means is much plainer and much broader. As long as there are two forces inside something pulling in different directions, tugging at each other, that's a contradiction. It doesn't have to fight or make noise. A lot of the time it's quiet. But it's always there.

Those days of mine "without any contradiction" weren't really without it. The contradiction just hadn't gotten in my face, so I acted as if it didn't exist.

One Line to Carry with You

Here's the core of this post twisted into one sentence you can pull out any time:

When you feel something is "going pretty smoothly, no contradictions," don't conclude anything yet. First ask: is there really none, or have I just not seen it, or not wanted to see it?

The weight of this sentence is that it flips the burden of proof.

Usually our default is: if I don't see a contradiction, there isn't one. Out of sight, out of existence. That's effortless and comforting. But dialectics asks you to switch the default: contradiction is the normal state, and "no contradiction" is the special case that needs explaining. If you really can't find any contradiction in something, it's probably not that it's flawless. It's one of two things: either it has stopped moving and is just sitting there, or the contradiction is still there and you haven't seen that side of it yet.

This isn't telling you to get paranoid and go digging for problems everywhere. It takes a weight off you: when a contradiction shows up, you don't have to panic or feel you're unlucky or that something's broken. A contradiction appearing isn't abnormal. It's normal. It actually shows that this thing is still alive and still moving forward.

Below I'll take this sentence apart with two of my own experiences. One is about "you can't hide from it." The other is about "it never ends."

Look Away, and It's Still There

Back to that habit from the start.

I really have done this, more than once. After sending a message I'm unsure about, the urge to look away right away is very real. My hand is faster than my brain, and slap, the phone is face down. Honestly, even in that moment I know it's a bit ridiculous, but I can't help it.

Then one time I was staring blankly at the back of the phone lying on the table, and it hit me: what I was doing was exactly like an ostrich burying its head in the sand.

When an ostrich faces danger, so the story goes, it buries its head in the sand. It probably thinks that if it can't see the danger, the danger isn't there. But the moment it buries its head, the danger hasn't shrunk an inch. Whatever was going to pounce still pounces. The ostrich just can't see it anymore.

When I looked away, I was doing the same thing. Whether they'd replied and what they'd said: the contradiction of wanting to know the answer and fearing it existed objectively from the moment I hit send. I looked away, it was there. I pretended to scroll something else, it was there. I put the phone face down where I couldn't see the screen, and it was still there. All I could change was whether I saw it. I couldn't change whether it was there.

That's the most helpless side of the universality of contradiction: it's objective, and it doesn't answer to your emotions. Whether you're willing to face it is your business. Whether it's there is its business. The two don't touch.

And think about how it ended every time. Not once was it resolved by looking away. Every time, I flipped the phone back over, opened the message, and took the answer. Avoiding a contradiction has never been the way out of it. At most it's a buffer, and once the buffer runs out, you still have to step over that hurdle yourself. In the minutes or hours you spend looking away, the contradiction doesn't leave. It just waits for you where it is.

Later I thought: this little habit is so common, everyone has done it, precisely because it hits the very essence of universality. Deep down we hope that "not seeing" equals "not existing," that a contradiction can be canceled by not looking at it. But it can't. On this, every one of us has been that ostrich.

Beat One, and the Next Steps Right Up

The second experience is learning to use AI.

These past two years I've thrown myself into learning how to use AI, and looking back, it's been a level that never ends.

At first what stopped me was the most basic stuff, so basic I'm a little embarrassed to say it now: how to download it, how to open it and use it. Even that I had to learn from scratch. Once I got past that level, I was pretty pleased with myself. I thought I'd gotten started.

Then the next one stepped right up. Knowing how to use it wasn't enough. I had to know how to ask. How to put questions to it, how to give it a role and write a setup so it would answer the way I wanted. That was another hurdle. I buried myself in it for a while and felt I'd gotten the hang of it.

Then another. Concepts came flying at me: what's Scale, what's an Agent. Each one meant building understanding from zero. Just as I'd got those concepts straight, I stepped through the door into coding and found that everything before didn't count for much. How to design a software development workflow, how to set standards, how to test: each was brand new and could stop me cold.

I'll be honest with you. Several times along the way I had the illusion that "I've finally reached the end." Every time I beat one, I had a faint feeling: that's about it, it should be smooth from here. Then the next problem showed up right on schedule and pushed that "I've reached the end" thought back down. Only after this happened a few times did I slowly see that the moment I kept waiting for, "no more problems," was never going to come.

What made this click was remembering the barrel.

How much water a wooden barrel can hold depends not on its longest stave but on its shortest. We all know that. But the interesting part is what comes after: when you work hard to fix the shortest stave, the barrel really does hold more water, but look down and another stave has immediately become the shortest. The bottleneck didn't disappear. It just moved. You'll always have a "shortest stave," unless you throw the barrel away.

Learning AI has been me constantly fixing the shortest stave. Fix "can't use it," and "can't ask" becomes the shortest. Fix "can't ask," and "don't understand the concepts" becomes the shortest. Fix the concepts, and "can't code" becomes the shortest. Every problem solved isn't the end. It just lets the next contradiction step onto the stage.

That's exactly what "contradiction all the time" looks like. Contradictions don't pile up at one point and then get cleared all at once. They run through the whole thing from beginning to end, one after another, like a metabolism.

And there was something here I had completely backwards at first. I used to take this endless stream of problems as proof that I wasn't learning well enough. Why are there always problems? Am I too dumb? Later I realized it was the exact opposite. The problems keep coming one after another not because I'm not making progress, but precisely because I'm moving forward. If one day I stopped running into any new problems learning AI, it wouldn't mean I'd become a master. It would mean I'd stopped where I was and wasn't going forward anymore.

Contradiction never ending doesn't mean this thing is broken. It means it's still alive.

Putting the Two Experiences Side by Side

These two experiences show two sides of the same principle.

Looking away after sending a message says contradiction can't be escaped. It's objectively there whether you look or not. Clearing levels in learning AI says contradiction never ends. It's there from beginning to end, and solving one brings up another.

One says that in space you can't get away from it. The other says that in time it has no end. Put together, they make up exactly the two meanings Mao describes: contradiction in everything, contradiction all the time. Combined into one sentence: contradiction is absolute and universal. It's the normal state of a world that is moving and alive.

And behind this drive of contradiction, present in everything and never letting up, is a bigger judgment in materialist dialectics: the world develops eternally.

We usually use "development" as a compliment, meaning progress, moving up a level. But the development dialectics talks about is much plainer. It just means the world is always moving and changing, the old constantly replaced by the new, never stopping at any finish line. And what drives it without end is exactly contradiction. Precisely because contradiction is in everything, there all the time, and can never be eliminated, motion and development never reach an end. The eternity of contradiction is the eternity of development.

Put that on my endless climb through learning AI, and it isn't abstract at all. Clearing level after level, fixing stave after stave, that endless process is itself what "development" looks like in me. It has no finish line, not because I'm not good enough, but because development has no finish line to begin with. So looked at the other way, it's actually reassuring: as long as there's another contradiction waiting for me, I'm still on the road of development. What's really worth worrying about is the day they all suddenly disappear.

Looking back, the tension I used to feel about contradiction came from a misunderstanding. I always treated "no contradiction" as the normal state and the appearance of a contradiction as a disruption of normal. So whenever a contradiction came, I wanted to hide, to wipe it out, to hurry back to those peaceful "no contradiction" days.

But there were no peaceful days. Either the contradiction was held down for the moment, or it was pulled tight right there and I didn't see it. The "no contradiction" state I was trying so hard to get back to never existed. I was wrestling with an illusion.

Before I Sign Off

So there's just one thing this post wants to hand you: switch the default setting in your head from "no contradiction is normal" to "contradiction is normal."

After you switch, a lot of things will feel different. A disagreement comes up in a relationship, you hit a snag at work, a long-term goal stalls halfway. At times like these, your first reaction is probably "what, another problem?" You feel discouraged, like something's broken. But if you accept the universality of contradiction, you'll know it isn't broken. This is just how it is. Something having contradictions doesn't mean it's bad. It means it's real.

Honestly, that's even reassuring news. It means you don't have to chase a finish line of "no contradiction at all" that doesn't exist, and you don't have to see every contradiction that shows its head as your own failure. Your job isn't to wipe out contradiction. It's to learn to deal with a world that will always have it.

But having said all this, a new problem comes up.

This whole post has been saying that contradiction is universal, in everything and there all the time. But if contradiction really is everywhere and everything has it, does that mean all contradictions look the same and should be handled the same way? A fat-loss plateau and the nerves after sending a message, getting stuck learning AI and a disagreement in a relationship: since they're all contradictions, does one method handle them all?

You can probably already tell something's off. These contradictions are clearly very different.

So beyond being "universal," does each contradiction also have its own temper, its own concrete face? And how do you get a grip on that difference?

That question will wait for the next post.

Licensed under CC BY-NC 4.0. Please credit the author and link to xiluluke.com/en/199

Xiluluke

A dialectical minimalist writing about life, reading and thinking.

Comments

0 / 2000Plain text · Line breaks preserved
Comment as

Loading comments…

    Your browser remembers your name and email once you post.

    Related writing

    WeChat · Xiluluke

    WeChat QR code for Xiluluke

    Scan with WeChat, or long-press to save the image.

    Open original ↗

    Buy me a coffee · Xiluluke

    WeChat reward code for Xiluluke
    WeChat
    Alipay code for Xiluluke
    Alipay

    Scan with WeChat or Alipay, or long-press to save the image.