Subscribing to AI Is Buying Yourself a Hoe
- No.
- 140
- Date
- Read
- 5 min
- Words
- 974
"The gentleman is not different by nature. He is simply good at making use of things."
—Xunzi, "Encouraging Learning"
A month ago, to talk with the Opus model, I paid twenty US dollars for a Claude Pro subscription. Now a month has passed. What have I done with it?
Put simply, in my creative system now, apart from the actual act of writing, AI takes part to different degrees both before and after I write.
Before writing, I often chat with Claude. We do have to watch out for AI hallucinations when we talk to it, but I have to admit that most of the time, Claude's finesse and sharpness are far above a human's.
I talk with Claude about many things. At the big-picture level, I talk with Claude about my writing plans. I remember one time we had a conversation of nearly half an hour about my wish to make money from writing.
My view was that I'd just keep writing slowly, and a path would show up on its own as I went. Claude didn't argue. In the end it told me: "'A path appears as you walk' doesn't actually conflict with actively looking for one. You're already doing the first. When will you start the second?"
At the detailed level, sometimes I talk with AI about a specific writing project. For example, the series of posts I wrote a while back about Xianyu (though it isn't finished yet). Even though I'm already an expert at using Xianyu, before writing I still chatted with Claude for a while. In that chat, we mainly settled how many posts the series would have, what each post's topic would be, and what to focus on, and in the end it became a series.
After writing, I also chat with Claude often. I rarely ask it how my post is. Instead, most of the time, I have it argue against the views in my post.
What's the point of arguing back? Of course not to deal with nitpickers. It's to widen my own perspective and add to my views.
I've written before that I think a view only ever represents one possibility of a thing, not that the thing really is that way.
So the world holds countless possibilities. Getting to know more views, within what I can accept, is a great way to train my thinking.
Also, after writing, I usually review the post I wrote that day.
I've always thought that for a blogger like me who posts every day, each day's post should be a collection of one or several views, like a slightly longer note.
What I do after writing is pull out the parts worth turning into notes, summarize and excerpt them, and add them to my flomo card library.
After extracting the notes, I argue against and critique the views in them, and then try to merge and recreate them with ideas from other fields.
That forms a complete review process: summarize and extract, argue against the views, merge and recreate.
What does merge and recreate mean? Simply put, you give examples for your own view, and those examples must come from different fields. You find where they overlap with the view, and what comes out of that is merging and recreating, and it produces insight.
Of course, producing an insight doesn't mean you have to use it. At bottom it's just a way of exercising your thinking.
Over this past month, I've used this process almost constantly to review my practice pieces. The material has piled up, and every now and then I flip through those earlier notes and find lots of things I want to write.
I never let AI take part in my writing process. For me that's a bottom line. You could say I'm stubborn, but there's not much to say about it. I don't actually dislike people who write with AI. For me, I insist on thinking for myself and typing with my own hands simply because I find spending an hour or two writing every day a pleasure.
I admit I do want to make money from writing. But I can't deny I also find writing great fun. If I used AI to write, I wouldn't get that joy, and even if I made money from it, I'd lose a lot at the same time.
So I never let AI take part in my writing process.
I've said a lot about how I use AI. But more important than how I use it is how I see my relationship with it.
I think my relationship with AI is like the relationship between a farmer and a hoe.
As everyone knows, the three elements of productive forces include people and tools. People use tools on the objects of labor, and what comes out of that process is productivity.
AI really is useful, and I enjoy using it. It's like when I was a kid, picking my favorite knife to take out to the field to cut vegetables.
AI is convenient enough that creating with it is like harvesting rice with a combine harvester. It's efficient, and the work gets done neatly.
But everyone knows a combine harvester can't go into just any field. When the field isn't big enough, or is hard to get into, or is too wet, it can't go in, and then you still have to harvest by hand.
Writing is basically the same as harvesting rice. You can use advanced tools, but you can't lose the ability to harvest yourself. Otherwise, the day the machine can't go into the water, you're in big trouble.
The more convenient the tool, the bigger the drop when you lose it.
So what I want isn't for AI to do the work for me. It's for AI to help me do the work better.