The Lobster Is Gone, but the System Remains

No.
111
Date
Read
4 min
Words
837

Keywords:

  • Attention
  • System
  • Trend Chasing
  • Blank Space
  • Information Environment

What can happen in forty-five days?

From the lobster blowing up to the backlash breaking out, from people paying for at-home installation to paying for at-home removal, in forty-five days a whole craze around the lobster (the nickname people in China gave the AI agent OpenClaw) came and went. Like a green field slowly drying out, it left behind a sense of bleakness and desolation.

Yesterday I wrote a post about why some people who missed this here-and-gone lobster craze still feel a sense of loss. Today I thought it over again and found something more universal behind it.

First, chasing trends doesn't just happen in tech. Our lives are full of trends like this that come and go. In finance, for example, gold and silver prices soared at the start of the year and drew in countless bystanders to invest, and then a sudden short-term crash left them lining up for the rooftop.

Around me, cycling went through a craze too. Roughly from 2023 to mid-2024, the cycling trend swelled like crazy. Countless people followed the crowd and bought expensive bikes, thinking that owning one would give them the free-spirited life and social circle of the cyclists on social media. But what usually happened was that a month or two later, a flood of secondhand bikes showed up on Xianyu.

The lobster stands for a tech craze, gold for a financial craze, and cycling for a lifestyle craze. Watching the people who swung between hope and worry in these three different crazes, I noticed they all rushed in, scrambling over each other, then hurried out just as fast. What they showed was a fear of blank space.

What is blank space? Take the three cases above and try answering three questions.

If I don't use the lobster, what else can I do?

If I don't invest in finance, what else can I invest in?

If I don't cycle, what else can I do?

This question of "if I don't do this, what else can I do?" brings a fear of blank space, because they don't know themselves what they could do instead. Or rather, they always feel they should be doing something, and they can't leave a single blank spot in their hearts.

There are always some tiny gaps in a person's heart. Even when they're tiny, some people still want to fill them.

The people who chase trends are exactly the people trying to fill the blank spaces inside them. They're just too restless, and they always mistake the noise outside for what they want inside.

The information environment we live in creates far too many needs we don't need. Before the lobster appeared, you didn't need it. So what suddenly made people feel they did? Your information environment. Your social media, with its constant stream of posts, gives you the illusion that everyone is doing this thing and you're the only one who isn't.

The thing that keeps pushing information at you and gives you that illusion is, at heart, a finely tuned system. What this system produces is obsession, unease, anxiety, and comparison, and without you noticing, it gets installed in your head.

That means if you don't consciously build your own system, you'll go on running a system someone else designed for you without ever noticing.

What's the difference between a system someone else designed for you and one you designed yourself? Our attention. When someone else's system gets installed in us without our noticing, it means our attention no longer belongs to us. That's a hidden kind of exploitation, because we're the owners of that attention, and we haven't noticed at all that something else has taken it over.

And when your attention isn't yours at all, you might jump into the lobster craze in tech first, then the gold craze in finance, and finally the cycling craze in lifestyle. All along you think these are your own free choices, and after trying each one, you find your passion isn't there.

Ask yourself: if a person truly knew their passion and put all their attention on it, would they keep hopping back and forth like this between fields where their passion isn't?

And the reason you can't find your passion is that you're living inside a system someone else designed. Passion is a byproduct of a system. When you build your own personal system, passion grows on its own.

If you really don't know what you want to do, that's okay. Sometimes leaving blank space in your heart is a source of calm in itself. It's like when I faced my almost completely empty living room. I thought for ages and couldn't come up with anything to put in it. In the end I found that leaving it empty was pretty nice.

Attention really is a resource, but holding it in your hand doesn't mean you have to spend it. Letting yourself leave blank space is a form of autonomy in itself.

Licensed under CC BY-NC 4.0. Please credit the author and link to xiluluke.com/en/5816

Xiluluke

A dialectical minimalist writing about life, reading and thinking.

Comments

0 / 2000Plain text · Line breaks preserved
Comment as

Loading comments…

    Your browser remembers your name and email once you post.

    Related writing

    WeChat · Xiluluke

    WeChat QR code for Xiluluke

    Scan with WeChat, or long-press to save the image.

    Open original ↗

    Buy me a coffee · Xiluluke

    WeChat reward code for Xiluluke
    WeChat
    Alipay code for Xiluluke
    Alipay

    Scan with WeChat or Alipay, or long-press to save the image.