Soul and the Human Question of Happiness

No.
261
Date
Read
9 min
Words
1,951

The unexamined life is not worth living. —Socrates

Movies are a strange and wonderful thing. Watch the same movie at different ages and it does something different for you each time. Take Pixar's movies. As a kid, you might not grasp the deeper meaning, but the visuals can still spark your imagination or just give you some simple joy.

When we grow up and watch them again, we're more likely to understand what the director and the creative team were trying to say.

I think of it as the surface and the substance. A movie's surface is its eye-catching visuals, its subject, its plot. Its substance is what the audience can only feel their way toward through that surface. Of course, a thousand readers have a thousand Hamlets. The surface everyone sees may be roughly the same, but the substance each person reaches, shaped by their own taste and experience, is different.

Soul came out in 2020. That year I'd just started college, and I was something of a movie lover, but for whatever reason, I didn't watch it until six years later.

While watching, I stayed pretty calm. The story isn't all that exciting, and the ending didn't move me much. But I still think it's a good movie.

Because I think it explores a question I've been thinking about for a long time: then what?

"Then what?" is a question without end. I've thought of a good example to describe it. In One Piece, the protagonist, Luffy, says from the very start that he's going to find the treasure the Pirate King left behind, the "ONE PIECE." For years a theory went around online: there is no ONE PIECE at all. When Luffy reaches the final treasure spot, he'll find a note that says you've already found the greatest treasure, the crewmates who sailed and fought by your side, and every story you lived through on the way.

Lots of people online weighed in. Some thought there really should be something you could call treasure waiting at the end. Others thought that ending would be great.

At its root, the question seems to be: what matters more in a story, the journey or the outcome?

The people who want a real ONE PIECE think the outcome matters more. The others think the opposite.

Here we need to make an assumption. Suppose the ONE PIECE really exists. When Luffy and his crew find it, "then what?"

We found the treasure. Then what?

Joe Gardner, the protagonist of Soul, isn't looking for any treasure. His lifelong dream is just to play jazz in a small club. Compared with his other job, as a contract teacher at a school, it doesn't seem like anything worth fighting for, except that he likes it more.

Like I said, Joe's ONE PIECE isn't much to look at on paper, but to Joe himself it means every bit as much as the ONE PIECE.

Once Joe finds his ONE PIECE, he asks himself: then what?

"So, what happens next?"

Unlike the ultimate question of One Piece, someone gives Joe an answer pretty quickly. Right, Joe. You've made it as the pianist in a band you love, and you get to play the jazz you love, but you're still asking: what happens next?

From the outside, "playing your heart out" is just banging away at a piano red-faced. By the same logic, playing your heart out every day is just banging away at a piano red-faced every day.

But nobody can go at something red-faced like that forever.

Just like Joe. When he learns he'll be playing there again the next day, he seems a little disappointed, though he doesn't know why. It just feels like none of it is any different from before. Nothing has changed. I once heard a story about a fish:

A young fish says to an old fish: I'm looking for this thing they call the ocean. The old fish says: The ocean? That's what you're in right now. The young fish says: This? This is water. What I want is the ocean.

Think about it. Joe's dream is to play in the band he admires. Fine. But dig deeper: what is he really after?

Is it the band? If it's just the band, why does it have to be this band?

Or is it playing itself? If it's just playing, why does he have to be in a band to play?

I think Joe's dream might be about both the band and the playing. These things can bring real satisfaction and happiness. Joe just hadn't found his anchor in them, and his attention had drifted away from the thing itself.

Let me use an example from real life. Take cycling. Some people love cycling, but bit by bit their attention shifts to gear. They decide their bike isn't good enough, their kit isn't pro enough, and they can't go out and ride.

But what does the joy of cycling have to do with how good your bike is? Whatever you ride, the scenery is the same, and so is what you live through. A better bike doesn't make the wind feel any freer, or what you take from the ride any deeper.

Through Joe, the director wants to tell everyone outside the movie to learn to examine their own lives.

In Soul there's a barber who says he originally wanted to be a veterinarian, but after leaving the Navy he didn't have the money, so he chose to learn barbering.

He doesn't feel defeated about not studying veterinary medicine. If anything, he's content with his job as a barber.

"I'm happy being a barber. Not everybody gets to invent blood transfusions like Charles Drew.1 I get to meet interesting people like you, make them happy, make them look handsome."

This barber really has examined his life. He knows exactly what choices he made, and he takes joy in them. That's part of what Joe is missing.

Let's make another assumption. Joe becomes the band's pianist and starts asking what comes next. Suppose he keeps building his career, and eventually becomes a world-famous jazz musician.

At that point, ask once more: "Then what?"

I find that question terrifying, because there's a whiff of nihilism in it. If Joe never figures out what happiness and joy he's actually after, then even if he achieves the biggest success the world can offer, it'll all be for nothing, because he can't take joy in it.

It's like with bikes. Lots of people keep upgrading theirs. They've just gotten a nice new frame and now they want a nice wheelset, then a nice power meter, nice cranks, on and on forever.

People's understanding of joy and happiness is a little off. Lots of people think they're a curve that keeps rising: keep chasing and satisfying your desires, and life will just keep getting happier. But in reality, happiness and joy both have a ceiling. The joy I felt when I got my first bike ever was exactly the same as the joy of buying my first bike worth tens of thousands of yuan. The happiness and joy Joe feels the moment he becomes the band's pianist must be the same as when he becomes a world-class jazz musician. Neither is higher or lower than the other.

So the happiness and joy a lot of people chase their whole lives, they already had the moment they were born. Back then we were all babies, and we laughed easily. Now that we're grown up, just to laugh, we have to do a whole pile of things to chase that result.

At the end of the story, Joe has his epiphany in the fish story. He realizes the most important thing in life is to carefully notice and live every moment of it.

So Soul carries a value I've always held to: real happiness only ever lives in ordinary, everyday life, not in a few big moments.

The movie also shows something else: if the universe hadn't suddenly shown mercy, Joe would actually have died in an accident.

And just minutes before he died, he'd gotten the offer he'd always dreamed of, to be the pianist in that band.

Set aside everything that comes after, and there's still a point to take from this: if happiness in life really came down to one moment, how would you know whether the happiness or the accident would come first?

There's an old saying that if you survive a great disaster, good fortune will follow. Maybe what it means is that only when someone truly realizes they'll die one day and leave this world do they start living every moment for real.

This is where I have to bring up someone else: the Russian writer Dostoevsky.

On this subject, he has every right to speak.

In 1849, Dostoevsky was sentenced to death for taking part in the Petrashevsky Circle.2 On the day of the execution, he and the other prisoners were marched to the execution ground. The sentence had been read, and the first group of prisoners had already been led up to the scaffold. Dostoevsky was in that first group. At that moment he was sure he had only minutes left to live.

And at the very last moment, the Tsar's pardon was announced.3

It hit him enormously. After he was saved, Dostoevsky wrote to his brother: he had wasted too much time in the past and never truly valued life. Now that life had been given back to him, every minute could become happiness.

For Dostoevsky, it was a "rebirth."

And his later novels, Crime and Punishment, The Idiot, The Brothers Karamazov, keep exploring one question:

If a person truly knew they were going to die, would they still live the way they live now?

Back to Soul. At the start, the movie introduces the idea of the "spark," and the audience naturally links it to "passion," assuming that everyone born into the world must have some passion or talent.

But later, the universe says:

I think that must have hit a lot of viewers hard. But what looks like a punch from nihilism actually carries a lot of real-world strength.

Do you really have to accomplish something, or have some talent or achievement, for your life to mean something?

If someone likes to go for walks and look at the sky, can't they find happiness in that?

Happiness is a skill, not something that's out there to find. People who can be happy will be happy no matter what, and the reverse is true too.

Back to the ONE PIECE question from the beginning. I used to take sides on it. I insisted there had to be a real ONE PIECE. That was years ago.

Now I have my answer: whether there's a final ONE PIECE or not doesn't matter to me anymore.

Because it was never supposed to decide anyone's happiness. For me, seeing the Going Merry's farewell, seeing Dr. Hiriluk's story, seeing the Summit War.

Seeing those things that have already settled into my youth is enough.

Footnotes

  1. Charles R. Drew (1904–1950) was an American surgeon whose research on blood banking and plasma storage helped drive the development of modern transfusion medicine. ↩

  2. The Petrashevsky Circle was a group of intellectuals in St. Petersburg, Russia, in the 1840s. They advocated utopian socialism and opposed serfdom, and were later crushed by the Tsarist government. ↩

  3. See J. Hillis Miller, Dostoevsky: Convict and Convert. This was actually a staged mock execution arranged in advance. The Tsar meant to use the terror of the moment to break the prisoners psychologically, and the pardon had been issued before the execution began. ↩

Licensed under CC BY-NC 4.0. Please credit the author and link to xiluluke.com/en/261

Xiluluke

A dialectical minimalist writing about life, reading and thinking.

Comments

0 / 2000Plain text · Line breaks preserved
Comment as

Loading comments…

    Your browser remembers your name and email once you post.

    Related writing

    WeChat · Xiluluke

    WeChat QR code for Xiluluke

    Scan with WeChat, or long-press to save the image.

    Open original ↗

    Buy me a coffee · Xiluluke

    WeChat reward code for Xiluluke
    WeChat
    Alipay code for Xiluluke
    Alipay

    Scan with WeChat or Alipay, or long-press to save the image.