Talent + ? × Fortune = Han Li
- No.
- 217
- Date
- Read
- 9 min
- Words
- 2,007
Lately I've been watching the anime A Record of a Mortal's Journey to Immortality.
I haven't read the novel, but that doesn't stop me from following the show. If anything, I think not having read the original means I'm not boxed in when it comes to understanding Han Li.
The title says "a mortal's journey to immortality." So what does "mortal" actually mean here?
From the point of view of people who don't cultivate, Han Li was born poor. If he couldn't cultivate, his life would be like most people's: work at sunrise, rest at sunset. A family and a life as ordinary as it gets.
From the point of view of cultivators in the Human Realm, Han Li has four spiritual roots, water, fire, earth, and wood, which by Human Realm standards makes him a textbook pseudo spiritual root.1 It's like being born with level-1 soul power in the Soul Land world, with Blue Silver Grass as your martial soul. The problem with a pseudo spiritual root is that it has too many elements, so none of them is pure, and absorbing spiritual energy is painfully slow. Even the lucky ones, without some huge stroke of fortune, top out at Qi Refining.
So whether you look at the Han Li of the opening episodes as a mortal or as a cultivator, he isn't anyone you'd call talented.
What is talent? If I step outside fiction and back into the real world, I might say: "Most people haven't worked hard enough to even get to the point where talent decides things."
But anyone who agrees with that has to admit it's also a backhanded admission that talent exists.
That's true in the real world, and even more so in fantasy. Novels with absurdly gifted protagonists are everywhere. In Soul Land, Tang San is born with full soul power and twin martial souls. That's talent. In Sword of Coming, Chen Ping'an is born with lasting martial fortune and the favor of all three teachings. That's talent. In Shrouding the Heavens, Ye Fan has the Primordial Holy Body and is unbeatable in close combat at his level. That's talent too.
Han Li, from the day he's assessed as a pseudo spiritual root to the day he forms his Nascent Soul, never shows any heaven-defying talent.
But for a cultivator with a pseudo spiritual root to make it all the way to Nascent Soul, there has to be something special about him.
That's where the title of this post comes in: Talent + ? ✖️ Fortune = Han Li
This formula is my own abstraction of how cultivation works. For a cultivator with great talent, you can crudely multiply talent by fortune, and that alone is more than enough to leave ordinary people in the dust.
But Han Li is different. He doesn't stand for those freaks of nature. He stands for the majority, the cultivators without much talent at all.
His talent is average, but he runs into plenty of fortune.
As of where the story is now, the Heaven-Controlling Vial, the Gold-Devouring Beetles, and the Heavenly Thunder Bamboo2 are huge strokes of luck all on their own, and on top of those things, Han Li gets plenty of fortune from the way his life unfolds.
The most important one is probably how, while he's still at Qi Refining, he ends up by sheer accident with Nangong Wan, a Core Formation cultivator. It looks like a fluke, but it has a huge effect on his cultivation.
Later an ancient teleportation array sends him to the Chaotic Star Sea, which is another enormous stroke of fortune. If he hadn't been sent there, there'd be no Void Heaven Hall, no Nine-Bend Spirit Ginseng, no Wind-Thunder Wings. He might never even have figured out the secret of the Heaven-Mending Pill he'd had from the very start.
Fortune might have something to do with Han Li being the protagonist. But if you give a protagonist fortune without the strength to catch it, the audience won't buy it at all.
So here's the question: Han Li's talent for cultivation isn't high. How does he catch one enormous stroke of fortune after another and make it all the way to Nascent Soul on a pseudo spiritual root?
That's the "?" in my formula. And as I see it, what goes in that "?" is Han Li himself. To put it more abstractly, it's the way Han Li does things. His character.
After watching a hundred-plus episodes, I think one phrase sums up his character really well.
Think three times before you act.
What are the three things to think about? Danger, retreat, and change.3
- Know where danger is and you can avoid it. That's thinking about danger.
- Hide where no one is paying attention to you. That's thinking about retreat.
- Once you've stepped back, you have a chance. Take your time to look and think: where did I go wrong, and what should I do from here? That's thinking about change.
Look back over Han Li's life and he's thinking three times before he acts, planning before he moves, at every turn.
First, thinking about danger. In the anime, Han Li's whole persona is built on one word: steady. Both the way the story is written and the way he behaves back it up.
When he gets things done, Han Li doesn't go for speed. He keeps looking for the lowest-risk option. In the Chaotic Star Sea, he hunts down a few remote spots for secluded cultivation, and "remote" really just means lower risk. On top of that, he lays array after array around his cave dwelling before he can relax. And when he's ready to sell the demon beast materials he's hunted, he doesn't just hand the whole lot to a big trading house. He disguises himself and sells them in batches, at different places and different times.
In a fight, Han Li spends a lot of time thinking. And however he thinks it through, his plan usually ends with running away. That's where his nickname "Han the Runner" comes from.
Which brings us to thinking about retreat. In any tangled situation, the first thing Han Li thinks about is: if things go wrong, how do I get out? As he says himself, it's hard enough for someone with a pseudo spiritual root to cultivate at all, so he can't throw his life away for nothing. Everything else depends on staying alive.
During the clash with the demonic sects, Han Li leads his fellow disciples from Yellow Maple Valley out to fight evil, and before the battle even starts, he's already set up an array to save their lives. That's why, when things go wrong, his group isn't wiped out.
Of course, anyone who's watched the anime knows Han Li isn't careful all the time. Right after he forms his core, he nearly dies on Extreme Yin Island. He takes Qu Hun, casts a concealment spell, burrows into the earth under the sea, and hides there for a whole month before he dares to come out.
And that wasn't enough of a crisis. After that, he goes exploring an ancient ruin with his neighbor, Fellow Daoist Jin, and walks right into a trap set by Xuangu, the Old Ancestor of Extreme Yin Island. He loses his clone, Qu Hun. If he hadn't had his Evil-Warding Divine Thunder on him, he'd probably have died too.
Han Li survives these brushes with death, but every time he pays a huge price.
And it's from these experiences that Han Li can think about change. He reflects on the moves that nearly got him killed, so that from then on he can be even more careful and focus on the Great Dao.
That's also what makes Han Li's growth feel real. He gets carried away sometimes too. He keeps changing through lessons written in blood, and keeps becoming a better version of himself.
So what does Han Li's story prove?
That in the story of "talent + self × fortune," when talent is low, the self can be the lever.
It can.
It just takes an enormous amount of effort, and an enormous amount of suffering.
As the theme song "Extraordinary" puts it, this road is full of a thousand layers of suffering that no one else understands.
Where do those thousand layers of suffering come from? We can't ignore the crucial part of the formula: fortune.
In the end, talent and self are both conditions inside a person. Fortune is a condition outside, completely out of your control. It's like ball lightning: sometimes you can't see it, but it's right there.
It only really exists once your own mind can observe it.
Fortune is the same. If your own numbers are too low, fortune can be right in front of you and you still can't pick it.
Like in the Void Heaven Hall, where low-level cultivators can only go as far as the outer hall, or simply die inside because they aren't strong enough.
To seize the best opportunities within your reach, you have to do more than plan before you move. You also need the nerve to fight and take risks. Strike when it's time to strike. And the moment you know one more step will put you in danger, pull back at once and use your escape route to get out in one piece.
"Think three times before you act" is something civil officials say. Generals have a saying of their own: "Put yourself where death is certain, and you'll find a way to live."
That's what the path of cultivation is like. You have to be "careful," and you have to "go all in." The two words look contradictory, but they aren't opposites. In different situations and settings, they connect in different ways.
And knowing when to be "careful" and when to "go all in" depends a lot on the person. That's why "self" is in the formula as its own element, and why it's the least predictable variable.
It touches every part of who a person is. And when someone makes all kinds of choices in a given situation, close calls are almost guaranteed.
This is what I think A Record of a Mortal's Journey to Immortality does really well.
They didn't make Han Li a genius. They made him an ordinary man who's careful to the point of being a little "sneaky." And those realistic decisions show what it's like for a mortal to struggle, and to have no choice, in a world much bigger than himself.
Han Li's story is about cultivation from start to finish, but to me, none of it ever leaves the real world.
Back to the formula from the beginning: talent + self × fortune = Han Li.
Geniuses are a story about the few. The real power of this formula is that it leaves a spot for the "?" for everyone with ordinary talent.
What you fill in is up to you.
Footnotes
-
Pseudo spiritual root: In the world of A Record of a Mortal's Journey to Immortality, spiritual roots are ranked by the purity of their five-element affinities. A root with four or five elements is called a pseudo spiritual root. Because the elements are mixed, cultivation is extremely slow, and it's considered the worst spiritual root of all. ↩
-
Heavenly Thunder Bamboo: One of the three divine woods (the other two are Soul-Nurturing Wood and the Spirit Eye Tree), and a top-grade material for refining a life-bound magic treasure. Han Li gets it through a stroke of fortune in the Chaotic Star Sea. ↩
-
Thinking about danger, retreat, and change: This comes from the TV series Ming Dynasty 1566, where Lü Fang advises the Jiajing Emperor: "Know where danger is and you can avoid it. That's called thinking about danger. Hide where no one is paying attention to you. That's called thinking about retreat. Once you've stepped back, you have a chance. Take your time to look and think: where did I go wrong, and what should I do from here? That's called thinking about change." ↩