I Ate Rice Noodles and Still Lost Weight. Are Refined Carbs Really the Villain?

No.
147
Date
Read
5 min
Words
986

Science doesn't deny intuition. It just asks you to put your intuition on a scale and weigh it. – Richard Feynman


Last night I had a plate of stir-fried rice noodles. I didn't use much oil, but it more or less counts as that sugar-plus-fat combo. And yet this morning when I stepped on the scale, I was over half a kilo lighter than yesterday morning.

A friend commented under my Xiaohongshu post: how are you still losing weight? Aren't rice noodles refined carbs?

Yes, rice noodles are refined carbs. But so what? They're refined carbs. And?

Weight-loss and fat-loss guides online keep repeating one line: "Eat fewer refined carbs and more whole grains (unrefined carbs)." So what are refined carbs, and what are unrefined carbs?

Refined and Unrefined Carbs

Refined carbs are carbohydrates that have gone through industrial processing until only the starchy core is left. Processing strips out most of the dietary fiber, vitamins and minerals in the original food. Our bodies digest these foods very fast, and blood sugar rises fast too. Typical examples are white rice, flour, crackers, bread, fruit juice and so on.

Unrefined carbs are the opposite. They keep the food's natural structure, and their natural fiber and micronutrients stay relatively intact. When you eat them, blood sugar rises gently, and the more filling they are. Think brown rice, oats, whole-wheat bread, sweet potatoes. These are the staples you see in every online diet meal plan.

This brings in a concept you'll also see all over the internet: "high GI" and "low GI." Put simply, a food's GI (glycemic index) tells you how fast it raises your blood sugar. The higher the number, the faster blood sugar rises. The lower the number, the slower.

One thing to keep in mind: GI measures speed, not amount. Watermelon has a high GI, but a slice of watermelon doesn't actually contain much sugar. White rice has a high GI, but if you only eat half a bowl, your blood sugar response is limited.

From that alone, you can see that most of the online advice that decides whether a staple is "allowed" based on its GI has an obvious problem.

Four Myths About Refined Carbs

First: refined carbs make you fat

This is probably the theory I've seen the most, or at least I've seen plenty of people who believe it. Eat one bowl of rice and you'll wake up the size of a pig. But what really makes people gain fat has nothing to do with whether a carb is refined. It's a total calorie surplus, folks.

Refined or unrefined, high GI or low GI, at the end of the day they're all just calories. During a cut, what you need to watch is your total calorie surplus for the day, not the chemistry of carbohydrates themselves.

Second: high-GI foods are off-limits

White rice and rice noodles do have a high GI. But GI is measured when the food is eaten alone, on an empty stomach. Almost everyone eats mixed meals. Hardly anyone sits there forcing down two big bowls of plain white rice. Once you add protein, fat and fiber, your blood sugar curve flattens out.

So judging a food purely by its GI is isolated, mechanical thinking. It takes lab data and slaps it onto real life.

Nutrition science has a concept called "GL" (glycemic load). It combines GI with the actual amount of carbohydrate you eat, so it reflects a meal's effect on blood sugar much better.

Third: when you quit refined carbs, what you lose is fat

Just like the first myth, some people think one bowl of rice will make them fat as a pig, and others think skipping one bowl will make them skinny as a monkey. Neither idea is scientific.

Quitting refined carbs basically means eating fewer carbs. Eat less or no staple food on top of your usual diet and you'll see your weight drop fast. But most of that is just water. To put it more technically, it's the water bound to glycogen, released when your body breaks the glycogen down.

This is a classic dieting trap. People mistake water loss for weight-loss success, feel a little proud of themselves, celebrate with a nice meal, and the next day find their weight right back where it started.

Fourth: eating refined carbs during a cut means you've failed

One extra bowl of rice. It's over, it's over, my whole cut is ruined by this one bowl. Forget it, I quit. Time to eat everything.

Is that your thought process now, or has it ever been?

There's really no need. Since when did eating rice become a moral issue?

When it comes down to it, refined carbs are just high in calories and not very filling. As long as the total is under control, eating them now and then won't wreck your cut.

Conclusion

So, in the end, the reason I lost weight even after eating rice noodles is that my calorie deficit for the whole day yesterday was large.

And for me, losing weight that fast isn't acceptable. My plan is to keep my rate of loss to about 0.55 kg a week, 2.2 kg a month, so I can finish my cut on schedule in three months.

The worst thing you can do during a cut is lose weight too fast. Not only is much of what you lose likely to be muscle, your health may take a hit too.

Most people's misunderstanding and fear of refined carbs comes down to confusing what a food is with how you manage calories.

The underlying logic of fat loss is the calorie deficit.

Refined carbs just make that harder to pull off, because they aren't very filling and it's easy to overeat them. But they aren't the enemy of fat loss in themselves.

Controlling the total is what everyone managing their weight needs to focus on.


Licensed under CC BY-NC 4.0. Please credit the author and link to xiluluke.com/en/147

Xiluluke

A dialectical minimalist writing about life, reading and thinking.

Comments

0 / 2000Plain text · Line breaks preserved
Comment as

Loading comments…

    Your browser remembers your name and email once you post.

    Related writing

    WeChat · Xiluluke

    WeChat QR code for Xiluluke

    Scan with WeChat, or long-press to save the image.

    Open original ↗

    Buy me a coffee · Xiluluke

    WeChat reward code for Xiluluke
    WeChat
    Alipay code for Xiluluke
    Alipay

    Scan with WeChat or Alipay, or long-press to save the image.